by Sheree Trotter
The reality is, there is not one Māori view on any topic, including Israel.
Those who claim otherwise proceed by disregarding the views of those with whom they disagree, or worse, by disqualifying them on the basis of some constructed set of rules, to determine who is truly Māori and who is not.
The matter has been brought to the fore in recent weeks because of fallout from an Israel government sponsored Māori delegation to Israel. This was not the first such delegation to Israel, nor the only Indigenous delegation. Indeed, delegations of various kinds travel to Israel regularly, as they often do to other countries. So why the controversy? Put simply, many Māori have bought into the idea that Israel is a rogue nation, the chief transgressor of the crimes of apartheid, colonialism and genocide. In their minds, even travelling to Israel is to be complicit in the crimes that Israel is supposedly committing.
Of course, most people who travel to Israel soon realize they’ve been sold a lie. Israel is a diverse, multi-ethnic, tolerant society where Jews and Arabs live and work side by side. However, outside the borders of Israel are Islamist terrorist groups dedicated to her destruction. Hence the security measures: walls, checkpoints, special roads, blockades are a part of everyday life for Palestinians in the disputed territories of the West Bank (Judea and Samaria) and Gaza.
It is a situation that has no parallel in New Zealand life. However, that does not prevent activists projecting New Zealand’s history of colonialism onto Israel. Indigenous activists claim that the Māori experience of land loss is just like the Palestinian experience, when in reality, the two situations bear little resemblance.
The irony of the Palestinian movement amongst Māori is that it is driven by Western ideologies, not by Indigenous ways of thinking and being. The Māori activist movements that began in the late 70s and early 80s were birthed by, and became inextricably linked with, international Marxist-inspired anti-colonial movements. The Soviet-Arab alliance propagated a virulent antizionist propaganda campaign which infiltrated western institutions like the UN. More recently settler colonial ideology emanating from universities has influenced Māori academics and lawyers to see Israel as the epitome of all the evils of colonialism and the West.
The fact is, that there has been a long history of Maori connection with Israel and the Jewish people, which began in the nineteenth century and continues to the present. We have covered this history elsewhere, from the Māori prophetic resistance movements of the 1800s, to the revitalisation of Te Reo Maori (the Maori language), to the beginning of the World Christian Gathering of Indigenous Peoples movement in the 1990s, the support of Maori Queen, Te Arikinui Dame Te Atarangikaahu, the various Māori delegations to Israel, Maori business connections in Agritech, connections around geothermal technology and ambassadors being welcomed onto marae.
Of note, given the controversy surrounding Ngāpuhi leader, Pita Tipene’s involvement in the recent Māori delegation trip, is the historical support for Israel from Ngaphui leaders since at least 1947. Five weeks after Tipene’s return from the government sponsored trip to Israel, the Ngāpuhi leader declared that Israel was, in fact, committing genocide in Gaza. He admitted that he didn’t go to Gaza and yet reached this conclusion after watching videos sent to him by relatives. This followed a hit piece by Māori broadcaster, Moana Maniapoto, in which she displayed unmistakable hostility towards two delegates who had travelled to Israel.
In the past decade, Ngāpuhi have held several hui (meetings) with Israeli ambassadors. Led by Kaumatua Pat Ruka, these included a
whakapaha ceremony held at Hoani Waititi Marae in West Auckland, to apologise for the 2016 UN resolution 2334, followed by an invitation to the Israeli ambassador to Kohewhata Marae, in the heart of Ngāpuhi, in which a “covenant” with Israel was made. A powerful powhiri for the subsequent Israeli ambassador HE Ran Yaakoby was held at Waititi Marae at Waitangi on Earth Day in 2020. Following 7 October 2023, another hui was held in the North to show support for Israel and to farewell H.E. Ambassador Yaakoby.
While it has been difficult for Māori Israel supporters in the past three years to fight the ongoing propaganda war, the resolve is as strong as ever. A new Israel support group has been formed by Pastors Harry and Kui Lazarus. Harry and Kui started hosting Israeli travellers in their home in the early 2000s. This experience combined with a strong Christian faith has given them a conviction to stand with Israel in the most difficult of times. Harry is Ngāpuhi and a cousin of late Matua Pat Ruka. He is the current custodian of the story handed down by their tipuna, of a love and commitment to bless Israel. In 1947 their grandfathers were part of a group of kaumatua who wanted to put aside land for Jewish refugees, Holocaust survivors in Europe. These elders travelled to the capital, Wellington, to meet with politicians and were told to return to their hovels. According to Ruka, their land was eventually taken and given to Returned Servicemen.
Pastor Lazarus has a passion to honour the wishes of his tipuna and to remind his Iwi (tribe) of the call of their ancestors to care for the Jewish people. Lazarus was present at the Northern hui (meeting) when a covenant was made with Israel. This is not something he takes lightly. He signed the recent joint statement highlighting the concerns for the safety of Jewish and Israeli people in this land, on behalf of the newly formed Te Oriwa Kotahi. He laments the way Jewish people have been treated and longs for them to feel safe in this nation.
So, while politicised Māori insist that hating Israel is the correct Indigenous position, there is a long history of support for Israel, from positions of faith, innovation, friendship, whakapapa (genealogy) and also Indigenous values of manaakitanga (hospitality) and aroha (love/care) for all people.

